Recfishwest’s position on mandatory catch reporting

We don’t need to count the fish better – we need to manage them better

Calls for mandatory catch reporting in WA’s recreational fishing sector continue to surface, largely driven by commercial interests and some media commentary. Let’s be clear: this is a solution looking for a problem.

Recfishwest does not support mandatory catch reporting for recreational fishers, and neither does the WA Government, whose current policy rightly reflects the strong evidence base and supports our position.

The data we have now is robust, world-class, and more reliable than most other jurisdictions globally. It is independently verified, statistically sound, and developed by the Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development (DPIRD) using rigorous, peer-reviewed methods.

Despite repeated claims, no proponent of mandatory reporting has ever provided any evidence that the current recreational catch estimation approach is flawed, or that mandatory reporting would work better. In fact, global experience shows the opposite.

Mandatory catch reporting doesn’t work – and the Kimberley proves it

If mandatory reporting was such a silver bullet for sustainability, it would have worked in WA’s overwhelmingly commercial Kimberley Demersal Scalefish Fishery – where it’s been in place for years. But it hasn’t. That fishery has recently been assessed as being at high risk of sustainability failure, despite mandatory reporting being fully implemented.

This shows that mandatory reporting alone doesn’t deliver sustainable outcomes. The system may collect data, but without effective management action, it won’t improve stock status. If it doesn’t work in a tightly controlled commercial setting, it’s hard to see how it would succeed in WA’s diverse, community-driven recreational sector.

We support what works – not what sounds good

Recfishwest is not opposed to new tools or approaches if they can genuinely improve fisheries management. We would support mandatory catch reporting if there was any evidence that it worked. But despite years of discussion and examples from around the world, no one has presented a workable model that delivers better outcomes than the system WA already uses.

Until that changes, we won’t support replacing a high-quality, independent system with one based on flawed assumptions and wishful thinking.

What would it even look like? Nobody knows.

There has never been a proposal in WA that outlines how mandatory recreational catch reporting would actually work, no detail on compliance, enforcement, user experience, privacy, or cost. Just vague ideas with no plan.

Where systems like this have been tried overseas, they’ve failed due to:
– Poor compliance and unreliable data
– Privacy concerns and community mistrust
– Lack of user-friendly reporting platforms
– High costs with little return
– No way to validate or verify what’s reported

Recreational fishers are doing their part

Recreational fishers have always stepped up, embracing changes, supporting science, and contributing to stock recovery efforts, often more than any other sector.

WA’s recreational fishing sector accounts for around 10% of demersal catch statewide, yet recreational fishers remain the most visible, engaged and invested in healthy fish stocks. In contrast, 90% of demersals and 95% of all seafood in WA is caught commercially.

If we’re serious about sustainability, let’s put effort where it matters most, into smart, effective management that improves our fisheries, not more red tape that burdens responsible fishers and adds no value.

Continue Reading

October 28, 2026

New science shines a light on Cockburn Sound’s unique environment

Scientists deploying bongo nets to sample for fish eggs in the Sound. Supplied by the Western Australian Marine Science Institution (WAMSI) as part of the WAMSI Westport Marine Science Program. Results from one of the…

Read More

October 26, 2026

Baby mussel growth signals next chapter for better fishing in Cockburn Sound

The Byssal mussel initiative of which Recfishwest is a founding partner is gearing up to produce the next generation of mussels in Cockburn sound with fresh spat (baby mussels) establishing itself on the farm’s…

Read More

October 26, 2026

King of the Reef delivers another year of fantastic fishing and surprising species

Four months of fantastic fishing, friendly competition and valuable citizen science have wrapped up in Exmouth, with the third annual King of the Reef competition once again showcasing the impressive variety of fish…

Read More

October 24, 2026

Snapper spawning in Cockburn Sound delivers eggs for next generation

One of Western Australia’s great natural events has been taking place beneath the surface of Cockburn Sound, as thousands of pink snapper have been gathering to spawn. Several reports of large schools of snapper…

Read More

October 21, 2026

Recfishwest AGM reflects on a pivotal year for fishing in Western Australia

Recfishwest’s 2026 Annual General Meeting at Fremantle Sailing Club gave members the opportunity to hear Board Chair Liam Surridge and CEO Dr Andrew Rowland reflect on a pivotal year for fishing in Western Australia…

Read More

October 16, 2026

Recfishwest on the road! A big weekend celebrating fishing across WA

From the Pilbara to the South-West, Recfishwest was out and about over the school holidays, getting amongst three fantastic community fishing events. Our team clocked up hundreds of kilometres and helped make plenty…

Read More